Argument organization | דף לימוד חלק ב׳ | רמה B2 (5 יח״ל) | גרסת הדפסה

דף לימוד ב⁨Argument organization⁩ לרמה B2 (5 יח״ל): הסבר קצר, דוגמאות פתורות ותרגול ראשון עם בדיקה.

הסבר

Four moves

claim → evidence → opposing view → answer. The moves are not always in this order, so read the signals.

Signals

Opposing views: Critics argue, Some people claim, It is often said. The writer's answer: However, Yet, Nevertheless.

Implied attitude

Evaluative words (welcome, sensible), so-called, quotation marks and promise-versus-result contrasts reveal the writer's view.

דוגמאות פתורות

Example 1 | role

"Opponents say parks cost too much." Role?

A reporting phrase gives other people's view.

תשובה: an opposing view

Example 2 | attitude

"The so-called shortcut added an hour."

so-called + a bad result = the writer doubts it.

תשובה: critical

תרגול

What is the writer's implied attitude? The so-called improvement made the buses slower than ever.

critical
supportive

Read the argument about school uniforms. Schools should keep uniforms. In one survey, most parents said uniforms reduced morning stress. Critics argue that uniforms limit self-expression. However, students can still express themselves through their ideas and activities. Copy the phrase that introduces the opposing view.

Read the short argument about school uniforms. Schools should keep uniforms. In one survey, most parents said uniforms reduced morning stress. Critics argue that uniforms limit self-expression. However, students can still express themselves through their ideas and activities. What is the role of this sentence: "In one survey, most parents said uniforms reduced morning stress."

the writer's main claim
an opposing view
evidence supporting the claim
the writer's answer to the opposing view